When trying to prove who is the better surfer, Fin and Reef get drifted out to sea, and end up on a remote island. Discovering they are the only ones there, Reef and Fin worry about dying on the island. They draw the conclusion that they will never make it back to their real lives, so the two prepare to kiss. At that moment, the rest of the gang shows up, revealing the resort was only 10 minutes down the beach. Meanwhile, Lo snags a vintage surf board tour to impress her dad. When things go wrong, the most valuable board goes missing.