Lauren gets a text from Carmine and she responds by telling him to leave her alone. Michael tells Lauren that he turned down a case where a woman, Eleanor, killed her husband and his mistress. Paul warns Carmine to stay away from Michael and Lauren. At Jack’s birthday celebration, Abby confronts Kyle about what is going on between him and Phyllis. Kyle receives a text from Summer saying that she and Jack are on their way to Jack’s surprise party. Later, Billy shows up drunk to the party. Meanwhile, Kyle tells Summer that they are moving too fast. Abby lays into Kyle when he tells her that he broke things off with Summer. Phyllis arrives at The Underground just as Nick reveals the truth to Avery.